Audit & Risk

Five tell-tale signs of poor corporate culture

A working group organised by the International Corporate Governance Network, ICSA: The Governance Institute, and the Institute of Business Ethics has identified a number of red flags that indicate poor culture.

in News.

Article Image

A string of corporate scandals at Tesco, Toshiba and Volkswagen have emphasised the importance of getting corporate culture right, but recognising early warning signs of poor culture and addressing them is less straightforward.  

However, a new report lays out a number of qualitative indicators that are all potential signs of a poor corporate culture. These include: high levels of corporate stress, flawed remuneration policies, complex legal structures, a tendency for takeovers to proliferate and lax financial discipline. 

The report, issued by the International Corporate Governance Network, ICSA: The Governance Institute, and the Institute of Business Ethics, represents the conclusions of a workshop of senior regulators, company directors and executives, and investors.

The workshop found that a major source of corporate stress was when corporate leaderships imposed short-term targets which staff found difficult to meet, exacerbating a rift between staff and management. In such cases the board was often unable to get an accurate picture of what was going on in the business.

Elsewhere, the workshop found that poorly implemented takeovers can lead to a multiplicity of cultures within the same group. As with complex legal structures, this can lead to silos and pockets of bad culture emerging unseen by the board. 

As well as highlighting qualitative tell-tale signs of poor culture, it added a selection of indicators that companies can measure, such as staff turnover, customer satisfaction, health and safety records, public commitment to values by leadership, competition rules infringements, regulatory sanctions, qualified audit reports and speak-up or whistleblowing statistics.

The report noted that more attention should be paid to the role of human resource departments, which are often charged with the task of embedding culture, and to internal audit, which is well placed to detect when culture is slipping.

For more ideas on how to spot and address bad culture, read the full report

The IIA: find out more

Visit the main IIA site


IT Audit Assistant Manager

Grade: Assistant Manager
Business Unit: Consulting
Location: Birmingham
Reporting to IT Audit Directors and Partners

Internal Auditor (Qualified Senior to Assistant Manager)

Grade: Qualified Senior or Assistant Manager
Business Unit: Governance, Risk, & Internal Controls – Public Sector
Location: London, City (Tower Bridge House)
Reporting to Internal Audit Managers and Partner
Key Relationships: Internal Audit Team, new and existing clients

Audit Senior

Grade: Senior
Business Unit: Audit and Assurance
Location: Poole
Key Relationships: Business Unit Leader, Appraising Manager, Assignment Team, Audit Managers, Audit Partners and Clients

Careers advice

Chartered by Experience

There is a new route to becoming a chartered internal auditor: Chartered by Experience.

Room to grow

If you feel stuck in your role or sector, yet are keen to progress in an internal auditing career, what are your options? You could become a non-executive director or contribute your experience to higher education, suggests Ann Brook CFIIA.

Time to volunteer

Rachel Bowden, chair of the IIA’s Guidance Working Group, explains why she started volunteering and what she has gained from the experience.

Training & Development

CPD: work in progress

Staying up to date is essential if you want to have a successful career in internal audit – and the IIA’s CPD competency framework is designed to help.

Tap into a rich resource

The IIA's website has loads of useful and important resources for members and the institute is committed to improving services by putting digital at its heart. So what is available – and where can you find it?


Mapping the road to assurance

Assurance maps are a vital tool that guide internal audits and give audit committees peace of mind. Sandie Dawson, director at Dawson Corporate Advisory, offers insight into effective assurance mapping.

Practical approaches to auditing culture

Corporate culture is high on audit committees' agendas, but few understand what to look for and how to measure something as nebulous and intangible as culture. Alexander Glebovskiy, internal auditor at an FCA-regulated firm, shares his advice.

Need for speed: risk velocity in control design

The importance of velocity as a risk assessment factor has been widely acknowledged by the risk management community in recent years. But so far the profession has largely failed to agree on a meaningful concept for measuring and weighting velocity as a risk factor. Maybe a simplistic approach can help, write Matt Rigby and Christian Thurow.